East Chicago Relocation Tests Limited Affordable Housing Market
Most families in a lead-contaminated public housing complex in East Chicago, Indiana will miss their first deadline to find new homes on Oct. 31.
It means they’ll get extensions through the end of the year, but why has it been so hard to find housing?
On a recent rainy day in East Chicago, landlord Clay Brooks drills open a plywood front door on one of a row of vacant houses and ducks inside.
“So this is one that we’re rehabbing,” he says. “As you can see, some things that need to get done. This is a three-bedroom.”
The little house needs basic improvements, like new electrical outlets, smoke detectors and bathroom updates. No one has lived here in a few months. The neighborhood is part of a federal toxic waste cleanup site — a Superfund — but no one here was ordered to move out.
It’s a different story in West Calumet Housing Complex, three blocks away. The Environmental Protection Agency has a similar cleanup plan across the entire Superfund, but the city ordered residents in West Calumet to leave. The complex is slated to be demolished.
Most of West Calumet’s residents are families with children, so they need three-, four- or five-bedroom units — which are few and far between in this area.
As of Oct. 21, the Department of Housing and Urban Development said just 27 families out of 332 who qualified for vouchers in West Calumet had found new housing within East Chicago. Another nine had moved away to other towns or out of state. That leaves around 300 families still searching, and still living at West Calumet.
Their first deadline to find housing is Oct. 31, but they can ask for an extension for up to the end of the year. East Chicago city attorney Carla Morgan says those who still can’t find new homes after that may be temporarily moved to other public housing in the city, where they’d have more time to find something permanent.
Landlord Clay Brooks stands in a unit he’s renovating in East Chicago. (Annie Ropeik/IPB News)
Brooks wants to renovate empty units, like the ones he owns inside the Superfund, to create more local options. But he doesn’t have all the money he needs to get the houses up to code.
“There are definitely things that are necessary to do before we can get anybody in here,” he says.
This whole area is contaminated, though, with lead and arsenic from an old smelting plant. Why would a family move from one place in a toxic waste cleanup area to another?
HUD’s deputy Midwest administrator, Jim Cunningham, says “finding suitable housing is not an easy process.” His agency paid for the city to build West Calumet, making it public housing. But East Chicago doesn’t have enough options like it to absorb everyone who’s moving.
Cunningham says authorities knew this from the start. He says that’s why they gave out housing vouchers for residents to use in other towns, even on the private market, with landlords like Brooks who will accept the vouchers to cover part of their tenants’ rent.
“At the end of the day, this is a Chicago metro region, so there’s plenty of affordable housing,” Cunningham says, or “available housing.”
A bulletin board at the West Calumet Housing Complex community center lists houses for rent. HUD is offering relocation counseling services at the center, but declined a request to interview counseling staff. (Annie Ropeik/IPB News)
In fact, the latest State of the Nation’s Housing census from Harvard University showed more than three-quarters of the poorest residents in the Chicago metro area, which includes Lake, Porter, Jasper and Newton counties in Northwest Indiana, spend more than half their income on rent, which constitutes a severe cost burden.
Rent for people making less than $15,000 a year in that area averages $770 a month, higher than the value of many vouchers that West Calumet residents received.
HUD’s Jim Cunningham says “the voucher makes it affordable” to live in places people couldn’t otherwise afford. But Indiana University law professor and former housing discrimination attorney Florence Roisman disagrees.
“You know what those vouchers are called, don’t you?” she says. “They’re ‘get lost’ vouchers.”
Roisman says landlords aren’t required to participate in the voucher program, so residents can’t necessarily move anywhere they want.
Eight states and Washington, D.C. bar landlords from discriminating against a renter based on their income source, such as a housing voucher. Indiana does not have any such statute.
It also doesn’t have inclusionary zoning, which would require new housing developments to include a mix of affordable and subsidized units, no matter where they’re built. That measure exists in states like California, New York and Maryland, and it’s also part of Bloomington’s long-term affordable housing goals.
But the only other federal tool to create affordable housing is low-income housing tax credits, which Roisman argues aren’t much better than vouchers.
Unlike inclusionary zoning, she says, they don’t force developers to put housing in safe neighborhoods with good schools, amenities or infrastructure.
“It’s making it impossible for people of color — for the most part, low-income people of color — to live any place except in a neighborhood that’s been labeled, ‘this is for low-income people of color,’” Roisman says. “And those neighborhoods are starved of resources.”
U.S. Rep. Todd Young has proposed an extra $8.5 million in low-income housing tax credits for East Chicago and Lake County over the next two years to stimulate development. But his bill doesn’t name specific neighborhoods where the credits should be used.
And even if that bill passes, landlords like Clay Brooks in East Chicago wouldn’t qualify — they’re too small-scale. Brooks has reached out to the city about getting money for repairs at his individual units, but hasn’t heard back.
And he’s unsure about investing too much in renovations. He’s worried that it’s only a matter of time before more contamination crops up, and more neighborhoods get evacuated.
“So it’s like — well, do we really rehab these units, and what if the people aren’t available to rent the units? You know what I mean?” he says. “So we’re, like, stuck in a hard place, I guess.”
What’s more, Brooks grew up right down the street, in a house where his elderly mother still lives. He planned to take a break from renovations soon to go get their blood tested for lead.
